top of page
Search

How to Break In a Baseball or Softball Glove Without Ruining It

softballmoms643
Nov 6
4 min read



You finally got the glove your player has been eyeing, and now they can barely close it. Before you try the shortcut someone swears by in the dugout, start with a little hand work and a few rounds of catch. The goal is a glove that opens easily, closes comfortably around the ball, and holds the shape your player needs on the field.


Do work the spots that actually need to bend

Put the glove on the way your player normally wears it and have them open and close it a few times. Notice where it resists. On many fielding gloves, the stiff spots are near the heel, at the base of the thumb and pinky. Gently flex those areas by hand, then have your player try closing it again. Let their natural grip guide you so you don’t force a crease they’ll have to fight later.


Do use a glove mallet to shape the pocket

A rounded glove mallet is handy when the glove is too stiff for a good round of catch. Set the glove open on a clean, sturdy surface and hit the pocket with the mallet towards the bottom of the web, where you want the ball to settle. If the heel still resists, work the thumb and pinky hinge areas a little at a time. Test the glove as you go. Once it closes comfortably enough to catch, put the mallet down and let your player take over. Wilson and 44 Pro both show how to use a mallet to shape the pocket and work the hinges. https://link.amazon/B0goE8Tmk


Use glove conditioner...but don't overdo it!

Make sure when you are conditioning your glove that you use a thin coat and follow the label. A little goes a long way. Skip the urge to reapply every time the glove still feels stiff. The padding and hinges also need time to loosen, and more product won’t do that work for you. Keep cooking oils, petroleum jelly, and other household substitutes away from the glove. Use a trusted glove conditioner such as this one from Rawlings https://link.amazon/B0goE8Tmk


Do play catch with the ball your player actually uses

Start with easy tosses and have your player close the glove around each catch. Use their game-size softball for a softball glove and a baseball for a baseball glove. That helps shape the pocket around the ball they’ll actually field. For a catcher’s mitt or first baseman’s mitt, add position-specific reps once it’s comfortable enough to use. Between sessions, put a ball in the pocket and use a glove wrap to hold the shape gently. Store away from extreme temps and moisture.


When your player is done playing catch, put a baseball or their game-size softball in the pocket, right where you want the ball to settle. Close the glove naturally around it and secure it with a wide rubber band such as this wrap https://link.amazon/A0dsOUzT5, a glove wrap, or an old shoelace. Keep it snug enough to hold the ball in place. If the tie is pulling the fingers out of shape or flattening the pocket, loosen it.


Skip these glove break-in shortcuts

Shortcut

Why I’d skip it

Running it over with a car

A tire puts pressure across the whole glove. You can flatten the pocket or distort the shape you’re trying to build.

Putting it in the microwave or oven

Heat can dry out the leather and leave the laces brittle. Keep it out of the kitchen appliances.

Leaving it in a hot car

The heat can dry out the leather and laces. Bring it inside after practice.

Soaking it or using boiling water

Follow the instructions for your exact glove. Wilson shows a controlled warm-water step in its own method, while BaseballMonkey recommends skipping water in its at-home shaping instructions. If you’re unsure, start with dry hand work, a mallet, and catch.

Saying yes to retail steaming without checking first

Even when a major retailer offers steaming, it doesn't mean its safe to use on your new glove. Rawlings says heat shortcuts can damage the glove and may affect warranty coverage. For my own player’s glove, I’d choose a no-steam method.


When a break-in service is worth it

If you’re ordering a stiff glove, such as a catchers mitt, and would like a head start, Headbanger Sports offers a paid glove break-in service for new baseball and softball gloves purchased from them. They describe a no-steam process that uses light conditioning, hand malleting, and machine work to shape the pocket and hinges. They aim to get it about 70–80% broken in, leaving the final shaping to your player. Check the added fee and turnaround before ordering, and make sure the glove fits your player’s needs first. Headbanger says the glove and service fee are nonreturnable once the glove has been worked on.


One last tip from the stands. Before you send the new glove into a game, have your player take it through a full practice. Can they open it easily, close it around routine catches, and find the ball quickly for a throw? If they’re still fighting it, keep the old gamer in the bag and give the new one a few more rounds of catch for gameday.

Sources for further reading

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page